How to Gather Customer Feedback Effectively Without Using Incentives
One of the best ways to gain insights into your customers’ thoughts is through surveys, but there’s more than one approach to running these. While many businesses believe surveys need to be placed on their website, this isn’t always the case. You can target loyal customers with personalised emails, thanking them for their business and requesting their feedback. This tactic feels more genuine, creating a personal connection that customers appreciate. They are more likely to participate if they feel valued, especially when it’s clear that their opinions will help shape the future of your business or online store.
Incentives can certainly boost response rates, but they don’t always provide the most honest feedback. Customers might tell you what they think you want to hear just to claim the reward. This could leave you with overly positive responses that don’t reflect the reality of customer experiences. For example, offering discounts or free products may result in more submissions, but this feedback can skew the results, making it difficult to identify genuine issues with your service. The team at Proof3 understands this, and often chooses to avoid incentives in favour of quality over quantity, preferring to wait for more insightful feedback.
An alternative method of gathering customer feedback is targeting users who leave your website without making a purchase. These visitors may be frustrated or confused, and providing them with an outlet to express their opinions can be enlightening. A simple slide-in survey asking, “What could we have done to improve your experience today?” can capture invaluable data. While not every visitor will respond, those who are frustrated will often leap at the chance to explain what went wrong. This method allows you to capture data in real-time and respond to customer pain points quickly.
Once you’ve gathered enough responses, analysis becomes key. Tools such as Hotjar and Typeform offer built-in functionality to organise and make sense of the data, highlighting common themes and trends. By using keyword density checkers or AI tools like ChatGPT, you can sift through the noise and identify areas where your business needs improvement. This data-driven approach ensures that your decisions are backed by real customer insights rather than assumptions, leading to meaningful improvements to your online store.
Optimising Customer Journeys to Identify Drop-off Points
Tracking customer behaviour on your website is a crucial step in improving the overall user experience. Many customers follow similar paths—searching for products, adding them to their basket, and completing the checkout. However, what happens when they don’t finish the purchase? Identifying drop-off points is essential for reducing bounce rates and increasing conversions. By examining the stages where customers abandon their carts, you can target these areas with specific questions or improvements.
For instance, imagine tracking the journey of customers who have looked at two or three products but left without purchasing. You could trigger a subtle question that slides in, asking them what prevented them from buying. This small interaction can provide valuable insight into issues customers are facing—whether it’s unclear product information, unexpected shipping costs, or simply a need for more options. Here at Proof3, we focus on these journey interruptions to pinpoint exactly where the customer experience falters.
To gain even more in-depth insights, you can use heat mapping tools to visually track how users interact with your website. These tools reveal which sections of your site receive the most attention and where users lose interest. You might discover that customers frequently abandon their carts after viewing shipping details, or that product pages with fewer images result in fewer sales. Heat mapping allows you to make data-driven decisions about which elements to optimise for better engagement.
In addition to tracking behaviours, analysing search data can reveal even more opportunities for improvement. By examining which search terms lead to positive outcomes—such as product views and completed purchases—you can refine your product listings and search functionality. Conversely, high-volume searches that don’t lead to conversions highlight areas where your site may be failing to meet customer needs. For example, a popular search term that doesn’t yield relevant results is an immediate opportunity to adjust your inventory or improve your SEO strategy.
Balancing Survey Response Quantity with Honest Feedback
When you start collecting customer feedback, one of the first dilemmas is how to balance the quantity of responses with the quality of the feedback. It’s tempting to run promotions or offer incentives to increase response rates, but as we’ve seen, this can result in biased, less useful data. Honest feedback often comes from customers who have a genuine desire to help you improve, rather than those who are motivated by rewards.
One approach is to extend the timeframe for your survey. By giving customers more time to respond, you can gather a larger sample without the pressure of an immediate incentive. Customers who respond after some consideration are often more thoughtful in their answers, offering detailed feedback that can help you identify both small and significant issues. This allows for a more comprehensive view of what’s working and what needs improvement, especially when compared to a quick promotional push that might flood you with surface-level responses.
A second strategy is to segment your audience when sending out surveys. Focus on your most loyal customers, who are likely to offer insights that reflect a deeper understanding of your business. These customers can provide feedback on the overall experience, from product quality to customer service, giving you the most reliable data. However, it’s also crucial to survey those who had negative experiences, as they can highlight issues that your loyal base might overlook. Understanding both ends of the spectrum gives a clearer view of your business’s strengths and weaknesses.
It’s also essential to manage expectations when analysing the feedback. Not all responses will be useful—some may be vague, irrelevant, or even offensive. However, once you’ve gathered enough data, common themes will begin to emerge. By using tools to filter through the noise, you can focus on actionable insights. We’ve found that sometimes waiting for that bigger, more reliable sample size pays off in the long run, as it provides a more accurate picture of the customer journey.
Using Exit Intent Pop-Ups to Capture Feedback in Real-Time
Exit intent pop-ups are a powerful tool for capturing customer feedback in real-time, especially when customers are about to leave your site without making a purchase. These pop-ups can be triggered when users move their cursor toward the close button or navigate away from the page, offering a final opportunity to gather feedback before they go. The key is to make these pop-ups as non-intrusive and customer-friendly as possible, ensuring they encourage engagement rather than frustration.
A simple question like “What stopped you from purchasing today?” or “How can we improve your experience?” can often reveal critical issues that otherwise go unnoticed. Customers who are about to leave are more likely to be honest about what went wrong—whether it’s product availability, confusing navigation, or pricing concerns. These pop-ups are especially effective because they catch customers at the moment of decision, allowing them to provide feedback while the experience is still fresh in their minds.
While exit intent pop-ups won’t capture feedback from every visitor, the data you do gather can be incredibly valuable. For example, if multiple users report that they were deterred by high shipping costs or an unclear return policy, these are actionable insights you can use to make immediate improvements. This real-time feedback allows you to be more agile in addressing customer pain points, reducing bounce rates, and improving conversion rates.
The challenge with exit intent pop-ups is ensuring they don’t interrupt the user experience. Timing is crucial—if they appear too early or in a disruptive manner, customers might become frustrated and leave even faster. To avoid this, use subtle, well-designed pop-ups that slide into the corner of the screen rather than blocking the entire page. This approach feels less aggressive and more like a helpful prompt, encouraging more customers to engage with your feedback request.
Leveraging Tools Like Hotjar and Typeform for Customer Insights
Hotjar and Typeform are two of the most effective tools for gathering and analysing customer feedback. Both offer easy-to-use survey features that integrate seamlessly with your website, making it simple to collect data without interrupting the user experience. Hotjar, in particular, is known for its heat mapping capabilities, which allow you to track how users navigate your site. By combining this with surveys, you can get a holistic view of both customer behaviour and customer opinions.
Typeform’s strength lies in its user-friendly design, which encourages higher response rates. Its clean interface and customisable templates make surveys feel less like a chore and more like a conversation, leading to more thoughtful responses. The team at Proof3 uses Typeform extensively for its ability to create engaging, dynamic surveys that adapt to the customer’s answers, ensuring that each respondent’s experience is tailored to them.
Integrating these tools into your customer feedback strategy allows you to track both qualitative and quantitative data. For example, Hotjar’s heat maps can show you which areas of your site are getting the most clicks, while Typeform’s surveys can provide context as to why customers are clicking—or not clicking—on certain elements. This dual approach gives you a more complete picture of the customer journey, helping you make more informed decisions about where to focus your optimisation efforts.
Moreover, these tools allow for the easy segmentation of your feedback. By targeting specific customer groups with tailored surveys, you can gather more relevant data. For instance, you might want to survey first-time visitors differently from repeat customers, as their needs and experiences are likely to differ. This level of customisation ensures that you’re collecting the most relevant insights, which can then be turned into actionable improvements on your site.
Heading
Incentives may lead to biased feedback, as customers might provide overly positive responses to receive rewards. Honest feedback is more valuable for improving your service.
Use tools like heat maps and surveys to track customer behaviour and trigger pop-ups that ask why they didn’t complete their purchase.
Personalised emails thanking them for their loyalty and asking for feedback create a genuine connection and encourage thoughtful responses.
Exit intent pop-ups appear when a user is about to leave your site. They can capture real-time feedback on why the customer is leaving without making a purchase.
Hotjar and Typeform are excellent tools for tracking customer behaviour and collecting feedback. Hotjar provides heat maps, while Typeform excels at creating engaging surveys.
Use subtle, non-intrusive survey pop-ups that appear at the right time, such as when a user is about to leave your site, to avoid frustrating your customers.
About the author
Ilan Butler
Share this post
Read more
